To Help or Not to Help

I’ve been reading quite a bit about parents who do everything for their children and shield them from failure, and how this affect the kids. Putting too much pressure on the kids to succeed.  I get that. I get what the goal should be as a parent: provide the child to develop as many coping mechanisms to deal with mean people, success, failure, disappointment, happiness.  But in practice, what do you?  How do you get to this goal?

Take the situation in our household. O is pretty sharp and witty (for a 3-1/2 year old).  But she gets into phases where she won’t do anything on her own.  I know she can dress herself. She can brush her own teeth. She can put her toys away. Make her own bed. Brush her own hair. But sometimes she reverts back to this baby phase, through tears she asks for help. I know what she’s doing. She’s trying to distract me from whatever it was she did that was not good. Distract from whatever it is I asked her to do. Get her own way.  But I know she can do these things on her own.

Last night, I told her it was time for bed, but she obviously doesn’t want to. So she distracts with many things including tears. I ask her (as calmly as I can because this drives me nuts) to go and start getting changed for bed. Then she starts. O: I can’t do it, Mommy. Me: I know you can, I’ve seen you do it. O: No, I can’t. Me: You have to try. Only babies, can’t dress themselves. And you are big girl. O: I’m a baby. Me: Don’t you want to be a big girl like [insert name here].  O: I don’t want to be a big girl. I a baby. Me: No, you are not. If you are baby then you won’t be able to go on your school trip on Friday. Silence… Me: Now, why don’t you show Mommy and Daddy what a big girl you are and go get ready for bed. O: No.  Can you help me?

This is the kicker. What do you say here?? She’s asking for help, but I don’t believe she really needs help. She can do it.  Me: I know you can do it. You have to try. O: More tears. And then she just scuffs off to her room. More tears. She comes back with her pants an underwear off, with just her shirt off. Her pull up in her hand, with tears in her eyes.  Me: You have to go get dressed for bed, I know you can do it.  O: NOOOOOOOOOOO!  This is where I lose. Me: O, if I finish loading the dishwasher and doing the dishes and you are not done, then no story.

I feel bad that I have to threaten. She goes back in her room. I finish my chores, and then she comes back.  All dressed for bed.  I make big deal.  Mommy is so proud of you! I knew you were a big girl. The tears are gone, and she is smiling. Then she says to me, I am going to brush my teeth by myself.  And her eyes get really big and she is super serious about it.  Will Daddy be proud? Me: Yes, he is so proud. I knew you could do it!

But is it right to let her cry and not help her out when she’s asking?  I do try to let her figure out things on her own. And yes, sometimes I do get involved if I think it’s not the most efficient way of doing it. I know that’s wrong. She needs to figure out on her own, and she does eventually get to the conclusion.  I don’t want to scar her for life by not helping when she’s asking for it. But I want her to know that I will help her when she really needs help. Not when I know she can do it on her own.

What do you think?  How do you deal with these situations?


About RidgewoodMom

Thirtysomething mom of a baby girl. First and only baby, possibly. First baby amongst my close friends. These are the trials, frustrations and lessons I have learned in raising a single child in New York.
This entry was posted in Baby, Family Related Event, Mommy Dearest, No longer a baby, So not fair, Social Ills and such. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to To Help or Not to Help

  1. Sam says:

    What do all your books say about it? I would say that’s what being a 3 year old is all about, being difficult, isn’t it? I know mine can do just about everything by themselves and somedays they do, but they seem to love fighting about not doing things the most…Or maybe at night time she is just too tired from the day and too crabby to want to do it??

    We have been focusing on reward jars, with beads for good behavior which is helping to ease the fighting. When they get enough beads in the jar, we go to the store for a new toy or present. We haven’t got that far yet though lol. It’s more my fault then theirs as I find the jar a bit of a pain in the butt…

    • RidgewoodMom says:

      Thanks. But do you help them when they are whiny and you know that they are just being lazy? That’s the question I struggle with. I clearly know she’s just in a mood. But I don’t want her to feel that if she legitimately needs help I won’t help her. Because I will. I just know that putting your underwear on, she can do it on her own.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s